Working with The Penny Mattingly Team
is easy as 1, 2, 3.


The Penny Mattingly Team consists of realtors Penny Mattingly and Tom Payton. Penny and Tom’s experience in multiple industries offers clients a unique home buying experience that is customer-service based. Our hope is that our customer service is so positive that you’ll come back to us any time you need to buy or sell a house. We are:

Meet the Team

Penny Mattingly

Broker Associate

Penny spent years in healthcare, where she developed a love of helping people. She took that passion with her when she made the switch to the real estate industry. Penny’s new passion is in helping her clients find homes.

Tom Payton

Broker Associate

Tom worked tirelessly to get his family’s small business off the ground as a marketing and sales specialist early in his career. This responsibility gave Tom valuable experience in perseverance and caring for others.

Looking for a home?

We genuinely care about finding the right home for each of our clients. Learn more about our service and see homes available in Greater Lafayette, Indiana.

Ready to sell your home?

We offer a unique approach to selling homes. Even if you aren’t buying a home from us, we can still help you list and sell your house.