Penny Mattingly

Broker Associate

After spending years in healthcare as a nurse, Penny Mattingly was encouraged by her friends and family to enter the real estate business. Her skills as a caretaker easily transferred to her career in real estate, and Penny loves to help people find homes. Though she thought the career change would lighten her schedule, she soon found that to be false, but that’s okay. Penny loves what she does and wouldn’t change it for anything.

(765) 337-6743

Email Penny

“I am most passionate about making sure my clients are treated fairly and that they get the best deal possible. I love to see the looks on their faces when they walk into a home and instantly fall in love with it.”


  • D.S.
    “We made the decision to work with Penny Mattingly not once but twice. I would highly recommend her to anyone interested in buying and/or selling a home. She sold our home quickly and worked hard to find us the perfect match when we purchased our new home. She has always been a pleasure to work with and she is very knowledgeable about the entire Lafayette and West Lafayette area. She is a realtor you can trust to get the job done!”

Meet the rest of The Penny Mattingly Team, and learn more about who we are and what we do!